
One great accomplishment by Bryan Singer (apart from the awesome "The Usual Suspects") was that he was able to convince all of us that Mutants too have feelings just like us; that Patrick Stewart & Ian McKellen were perfect as Professor X & Magneto respectively; & Wolverine was a much more interesting character & far more charismatic than Cyclops & Storm combined ... and that he achieved them all in ONE FILM - The X-Men.
He continued to perform even better with X-Men 2 with far more engaging characters like the Night Crawler and with deeper thoughts & stronger character development. In a nutshell, Singer left us wanting more of X-Men & that was why X-Men 3 was so hugely anticipated & broke box office records in its first week of release in the US alone.
One small thing that the producers forgot to take note was that Singer's handiwork was a tough act to follow, and whoever gets the arduous task to emulate Singer's feat would have to either equal if not better the first two installments. That task was left for Brett Ratner to fill ... and to be fair, he did quite a reasonable job, albeit not up to full expectation (especially to ardent followers).
Where Singer was rather meticulous and tidy about details and character development in the first two features, Ratner was rather brash in his artwork and approach, that when I left the movie hall, I felt very little connection with the characters, apart from the fact that I already knew them in the first two installments. I was of course excited about the third - hoping to see more mutants being introduced. And of course, hoping that there would be a probable glimpse of the 4th installment.
I was slightly taken aback by the treatment. The story and the camerawork were rather patchy and inconsistent. Perhaps, the only emotionally charged moment was when Prof. Xavier suffered a fatal doom in his encounter with Jean Grey. Hence, all that has been built over the two great episodes were left unmatched as the third series appeared somewhat lame and plausibly forgettable at times.
Which is quite a waste considering the strong foundation that it was built upon - a series full of promises and more exciting characters e.g. Beast (played by gasp... Kelsey Grammer!!!).
Singer justified himself with "Superman Returns". But Ratner, coming from the success of the action-comedy "Rush Hour 1 & 2", was no match for Singer.
How I wish it was Christopher Nolan who had taken over from Singer when he left... geez, what a wishful thinking!